About Big Jim's Pizzeria
For over 50 years, Big Jim's Pizzeria has been a New Milford institution — a family-owned neighborhood spot that's earned its reputation across Bergen County for classic New Jersey-style pies, hearty pasta dishes, and friendly service that keeps locals coming back. Grab a slice for a quick bite, settle in for a calzone and a plate of pasta, or order online for takeout. Extra crispy crust? Just ask — we're happy to make it your way.
A Gallery of Flavors
What our guests are saying
Every time I place an order, it's made fresh and in the time they say. I enjoy their plain cheese pie. There is something so simple and soulful about it. Thank you, Big Jims
— Leslie L
I grew up in New Milford, Big Jim’s pizza is the absolute BEST pizza ever!!!
— Colleen S
Big Jim's pizza is great - we think the best pizza in NJ. The people at Jim's are the nicest and so accommodating.
— Leigh L
Frequently Asked Questions
What is Big Jim's Pizzeria known for?
Big Jim's Pizzeria is known for Pizza, Calzones, Stromboli, Pasta, Salads, Burgers, Seafood, and Appetizers.
Where is Big Jim's Pizzeria located?
Big Jim's Pizzeria is located at 281 Main St, New Milford, NJ.
What areas does Big Jim's Pizzeria serve?
Big Jim's Pizzeria serves New Milford, Oradell, Dumont, Haworth, River Edge, Bergenfield, Emerson, Paramus, Cresskill, Westwood, Demarest, Closter, Harrington Park, Maywood, Teaneck, Washington, Tenafly, Hackensack, Rochelle Park, and Englewood.
What are Big Jim's Pizzeria's hours?
Mon–Thu 11am – 8:30pm, Fri 11am – 9:30pm, Sat 11am – 8:30pm, Sun 11am – 7:30pm
Does Big Jim's Pizzeria offer takeout?
Yes — Big Jim's Pizzeria offers takeout. Order directly online.
Can I order online from Big Jim's Pizzeria?
Yes — you can order directly from Big Jim's Pizzeria online for pickup or delivery.